The short answer
Repair wins when the slab is structurally sound, cracks, surface wear and one or two settled sections ($7–$15/sq ft). Replacement wins when the base has failed, the slab has broken into shifting pieces, or repairs would pass 50% of replacement cost ($12–$20/sq ft new in the GTA). Most driveways we assess are repairable; the assessment checks the base, the cracks and the drainage to confirm it.

When repair suits the driveway
If the cracks are stable, the damage is surface-level (scaling, pitting, spalled edges), and the base underneath is sound, repair and resurfacing are usually the smart, cost-effective route. A sound slab with a tired surface does not need to be torn out. It needs the damage repaired and a protective finish so it stops deteriorating.
When to replace, fully or partly
Full replacement earns its cost when cracks run full-depth across the slab, the base has failed or washed out, sections have heaved or settled badly, or the original pour was simply too thin to hold a repair. In those cases a repair is money spent on borrowed time.
Between the two sits the option that rarely gets offered because it takes more effort to scope: partial replacement. Remove and re-pour the failed section, repair and seal the rest. When it fits, it is often the best value on the table, and a good quote prices it as its own line.
Why it failed decides the answer
Before repair or replace, ask why it failed. If a downspout or grading is sending water under the slab, even a brand-new driveway will crack and settle in time. Fixing the water is part of any driveway job done right, whichever route you take.
Key takeaways
- Repair suits stable cracks, surface damage and a sound base.
- Replace when cracks are full-depth, the base failed, or the pour was too thin.
- Partial replacement is often the best value and is under-offered.
- Fix the water source or any new driveway will fail too.
Frequently asked
How long should a concrete driveway last?
A well-built, sealed and maintained concrete driveway can last decades. Neglect (no sealing, poor drainage) is what shortens it, not the material.
Is resurfacing an option for a worn driveway?
Often, when the slab is structurally sound. Resurfacing puts a new face on the existing slab; it is not a fix for a failed base.
See it doneWhat a good replacement looks like, finishedView →